Reality check on Indo-Pak détente

‘Merely promising prosecution of some of those involved in 26/11 is not going to get us all holding hands and singing Kumbaya in a church choir.’

“Their national character hasn’t suddenly changed,” said the senior officer in India’s security establishment, referring to Pakistan in the context of the glimmerings of the promise of rapprochement last week.

The apparent beginnings of a semblance of cooperation by Pakistan on the investigation and prosecution of those responsible for the 26/11 attacks on Mumbai last year and the upcoming meeting between the Indian and Pakistan Prime Ministers at the Non-Aligned Movement (NAM) summit at Sharm el Sheikh in the Egyptian Sinai have led some to hesitantly dare to wonder of the possibilities of progress in dispute resolution between India and Pakistan.

“Until there is substantial progress on pinning down terrorism directed towards India and emanating from Pakistan, there’s no call to get excited about prospects,” says the brasshat, presenting a reality check.

“This is about Pakistan turning its long-standing policies on their heads. It’s not going to happen overnight,” he says.

He says this, notwithstanding Pakistan President Asif Ali Zardari’s admission of his country’s role in directing terrorism towards India, as well as the recent signs of progress in Pakistan’s prosecution of those responsible for the 26/11 Mumbai attacks.

“Minor interactions with the Pakistani security establishment, even the ISI (Inter Services Intelligence) are not going to turn things around,” says the officer.

“This is not just about India and Pakistan in the context of terrorism in a vacuum. There are external linkages as well. How much would the Chinese like an Indo-Pak rapprochement?” he asks, querying further, “Would Pakistan be willing to accept the sanctity of the Line of Control (LoC)?”

“Merely promising prosecution of some of those involved in 26/11 is not going to get us all holding hands and singing Kumbaya in a church choir,” he points out.

The subsequent raising of interested eyebrows after the declaration of Major General Athar Abbas, Director General of Pakistan’s Inter Services Public Relations that the Pakistan military is in contact with Taliban leader Mullah Omar and can facilitate a peace dialogue between the Taliban and the US is also giving cause for smirking. General Abbas also said Pakistan wanted concessions from Washington with respect to India in return.

“I don’t dispute that they may be in contact with him. Quite possible, likely even. What I find myself in a dilemma about here is whether to believe the US to be too gullible or too clever,” he says, explaining, “A Pakistani statement like this generates hope. The US needs to recognize that this statement is meant to ultimately generate money and weapons for Pakistan that will ultimately be pointed at India.”

Tags: , , , , , , , , ,

Follow Saurabh Joshi on Twitter @ http://www.twitter.com/saurabhjoshi Saurabh is a journalist based in New Delhi, India who has worked in print, television as well as internet news media. Besides defense and strategy, his past assignments have included reporting from Kashmir, coverage of terror strikes as well as election coverage from all over India. He has a Bachelors degree in Journalism (Honors) as well as a law degree (LLB), both from the University of Delhi.
  • akshay

    Good Article .. i wonder why GOI cannot see that US is playing double game here. THe FOT(fight on terror) is all about their own security and also has the advantage of servicing the military-industrial complex in the US

  • akshay

    Good Article .. i wonder why GOI cannot see that US is playing double game here. THe FOT(fight on terror) is all about their own security and also has the advantage of servicing the military-industrial complex in the US

China launches Asia’s largest helicopter

The move marks the official approval for the 13-tonne AC313, Asia’s largest helicopter, to enter the market, said the Aviation Industry Corp of China (AVIC), which developed and manufactured the helicopter. The company says the AC313 is also world’s first civil helicopter to receive an A-category airworthiness certificate at an altitude of 4,500 meters.

Share

Fake cadet nabbed from NDA campus

Fake cadet Anmol Banotra was found when authorities at India’s tri-service, National Defense Academy, realized that there was a cadet more than their regular count. He was arrested on Wednesday.

Share

Mirage jets to get new missiles in $1.23 bn deal

French firm MBDA will supply 450 MICA interception and aerial combat missiles as part of the second phase of plans for upgrading the Mirage fleet of the Indian Air Force (IAF). India had last July signed a $2.4 billion deal with French defense firms Thales and Dassault for upgrading the Mirages.

Share

Army’s artillery buy in a confused mess

In the background of these challenges and the defence ministry’s inaction on a decision to blacklist the Singapore-based company, the OFB mandate should not become an excuse for lack of movement on the procurement of artillery by the army. Already, the ministry has been reported to have indicated it cannot move on the procurement as the matter is sub judice. At the same time, it has not decided the issue either, as is evident from the observations of the court. This has held up the acquisition of crucial types of artillery again, after the multiple cancellation of tenders since the Bofors buy.

Share

Letter on army chief my personal opinion: Amarinder

In a clarification issued here after it was reported that Former Punjab chief minister, Amarinder Singh had favored correcting the birth records of the army chief in a letter to letter he wrote to Defense Minister Arackaparambil Kurian Antony, the state Congress president said he had written the letter about a month ago putting forth his “opinion on the issue” only in his “personal capacity”.

Share

Iran warns US battleship to keep out of Gulf

Iran’s military leadership Tuesday warned a US aircraft carrier to keep out of the Persian Gulf. The warning from army commander Major General Ataollah Salehi comes after a 10-day Iranian naval exercise ended in the Strait of Hormuz.

Share
View in: Mobile | Standard