Rafale ejection from MMRCA race confirmed

Sources in the Indian Ministry of Defense told StratPost the aircraft was out of the running for failure to meet the General Staff Qualitative Requirements (GSQR) during the technical evaluation. Read the whole story behind the reasons for the disqualification of Dassault's aircraft.

S tratPost can confirm the scratching of Dassault’s horse in the Medium Multi Role Combat Aircraft (MMRCA) race, the Rafale.

Sources in the Ministry of Defense informed StratPost the aircraft was rejected for not being up to par as far as the technical requirements were concerned. “One issue was about power. The evaluating team was not impressed with the Thrust/Weight ratio,” one source told StratPost.


The Thrust/Weight ratio decide the maneuverability of the aircraft. The Rafale is reputed to have a Thrust/Weight ratio of 1.13. Interestingly, other contenders like the Lockheed Martin’s F-16 and Saab’s Gripen are reputed to have lower ratios of 1.095 and 0.94 respectively, while Boeing’s F/A-18E/F Super Hornet is said to have a ratio of 0.93. The Russian MiG-35 is said to have a ratio of 1.1 and the Eurofighter Typhoon 1.18.

In the case of Rafale, StratPost was informed the ratio was found to be unsatisfactory.

The Rafale was also said to have unspecified problems with its payload deployment system itself.

A crewman performs a post-flight check on a Armee de l'Air (French Air Force) Rafale B fighter at Nellis Air Force Base, Nevada (USA), on 7 August 2008. The French Rafale was from Escadre de Chasse 2/7 "Provence" (Fighter Squadron 2/7) from St. Dizier air base, Champagne-Ardennes region, France. The "Red Flag 08-4" exercise was an two-week exercise that pits forces in a realistic aerial "battlefield" to hone the fighting skills of American and allied airmen. Republic of Korea, Indian, Navy and Air Force teams were joining the French Air Force in Red Flag 08-4.

Other sources told StratPost, the Indian Air Force (IAF) was not impressed with the serviceability of the aircraft. At Exercise Red Flag in the United States last year, in which both the IAF as well as the French Air Force Rafales participated, the Rafales were observed to suffer considerable down time, which, according to some reports, was due to the lack of available spares.

Added to all this is the perception of the Rafale as an extremely expensive aircraft in comparison to its competitors, all five of whom are left in the race for the single largest defense contract in the world, for 126 fighter aircraft, said to be worth $ 12 billion.

But sources in the Ministry of defense have also expressed frustration at the lack of an official communique disqualifying Dassault’s Rafale from the race. “I don’t understand why they can’t issue an official note, if they have indeed made up their minds. Why do these games have to be played during election time?” asked one source.

Tags: , , , , , , ,

Follow Saurabh Joshi on Twitter @ http://www.twitter.com/saurabhjoshi Saurabh is a journalist based in New Delhi, India who has worked in print, television as well as internet news media. Besides defense and strategy, his past assignments have included reporting from Kashmir, coverage of terror strikes as well as election coverage from all over India. He has a Bachelors degree in Journalism (Honors) as well as a law degree (LLB), both from the University of Delhi.


  1. […] StratPost, an unnamed source was bitter at the decision, especially in light of StratPost’s report on the reasons for the rejection. “Look if it is really about something like Thrust/Weight […]

  2. […] Post says the Israeli Air Force is reviewing specifications for the F-15 Silent Eagle Indian aerospace blogger Saurabh Joshi confirms and dissects reports of the Dassault Rafale’s ejection from the Indian multi-role combat […]

  3. […] to recent reports about the rejection, including by StratPost, he said, “People have made their own interpretations and assumptions. People have been […]

  4. […] Eurofighter Typhoon and French Dassault’s Rafale, which had been earlier reported to have crashed from the race. Tags: Air Chief Marshal Fali Homi Major, Boeing, Dassault, DRDO, EADS, Eurofighter Typhoon, […]

  5. […] 29. Rafale was once thrown out of the contest. […]

  6. […] aerospace blogger Saurabh Joshi confirms and dissects reports of the Dassault Rafale’s ejection from the Indian multi-role […]

Switch to our mobile site