Comments on: Indian Army tasking to Afghanistan faces multiple roadblocks http://www.stratpost.com/indian-army-tasking-to-afghanistan-faces-multiple-roadblocks South Asian Defense & Strategic Affairs Tue, 07 Feb 2012 17:17:44 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.3.1 By: Pranav_aquarian http://www.stratpost.com/indian-army-tasking-to-afghanistan-faces-multiple-roadblocks/comment-page-1#comment-3146 Pranav_aquarian Wed, 02 Mar 2011 07:41:00 +0000 http://www.stratpost.com/?p=1040#comment-3146 i do not like the idea of India behaving like a great power before time; we are well placed to establish good will with the afghan people and govt. through exercise of soft power + extend training support to afghan security forces. military involvement in afghanistan without UN sponsorship, seems to be a cavalier idea. moreover, lets not overestimate our experience or success in COIN...LTTE experience reminds the difference between doing it domestically as against in somebody else's country. i do not like the idea of India behaving like a great power before time; we are well placed to establish good will with the afghan people and govt. through exercise of soft power + extend training support to afghan security forces. military involvement in afghanistan without UN sponsorship, seems to be a cavalier idea.

moreover, lets not overestimate our experience or success in COIN…LTTE experience reminds the difference between doing it domestically as against in somebody else’s country.

]]> By: Afghan Army to train in India | StratPost http://www.stratpost.com/indian-army-tasking-to-afghanistan-faces-multiple-roadblocks/comment-page-1#comment-2695 Afghan Army to train in India | StratPost Wed, 23 Jun 2010 19:25:41 +0000 http://www.stratpost.com/?p=1040#comment-2695 [...] chief General Bismillah Khan Mohammadi and the Indian Army and the Ministry of Defense during his visit to New Delhi last July. India has so far been non-committal about sending training personnel to Afghanistan for [...] [...] chief General Bismillah Khan Mohammadi and the Indian Army and the Ministry of Defense during his visit to New Delhi last July. India has so far been non-committal about sending training personnel to Afghanistan for [...]

]]> By: Does finishing the job mean staying the course? | StratPost http://www.stratpost.com/indian-army-tasking-to-afghanistan-faces-multiple-roadblocks/comment-page-1#comment-2360 Does finishing the job mean staying the course? | StratPost Mon, 30 Nov 2009 16:11:54 +0000 http://www.stratpost.com/?p=1040#comment-2360 [...] are also creeping apprehensions of Afghanistan reverting to a pre-9/11 state, if the US were to up and leave before time. “Say if they leave one day, what would happen? There would be a vacuum there. [...] [...] are also creeping apprehensions of Afghanistan reverting to a pre-9/11 state, if the US were to up and leave before time. “Say if they leave one day, what would happen? There would be a vacuum there. [...]

]]> By: akshay http://www.stratpost.com/indian-army-tasking-to-afghanistan-faces-multiple-roadblocks/comment-page-1#comment-918 akshay Mon, 31 Aug 2009 09:18:12 +0000 http://www.stratpost.com/?p=1040#comment-918 The strategy needs to be thought out, firstly do no enter till the US requests help. We don't need to rush,we have defeated Pak from One side earlier. But India should start preparing in the form of Infra and Medico Aid to afghanis so that after 3-4 years when we deploy we will have the local populace on our side. What logistical issues,may i ask ?? the whole CIS and Russia is present, we just need USD$ from the US congress to fund us. The strategy needs to be thought out, firstly do no enter till the US requests help. We don’t need to rush,we have defeated Pak from One side earlier.

But India should start preparing in the form of Infra and Medico Aid to afghanis so that after 3-4 years when we deploy we will have the local populace on our side.

What logistical issues,may i ask ?? the whole CIS and Russia is present, we just need USD$ from the US congress to fund us.

]]> By: akshay http://www.stratpost.com/indian-army-tasking-to-afghanistan-faces-multiple-roadblocks/comment-page-1#comment-2859 akshay Mon, 31 Aug 2009 09:18:00 +0000 http://www.stratpost.com/?p=1040#comment-2859 The strategy needs to be thought out, firstly do no enter till the US requests help. We don't need to rush,we have defeated Pak from One side earlier. But India should start preparing in the form of Infra and Medico Aid to afghanis so that after 3-4 years when we deploy we will have the local populace on our side. What logistical issues,may i ask ?? the whole CIS and Russia is present, we just need USD$ from the US congress to fund us. The strategy needs to be thought out, firstly do no enter till the US requests help. We don’t need to rush,we have defeated Pak from One side earlier.

But India should start preparing in the form of Infra and Medico Aid to afghanis so that after 3-4 years when we deploy we will have the local populace on our side.

What logistical issues,may i ask ?? the whole CIS and Russia is present, we just need USD$ from the US congress to fund us.

]]>